Wednesday, 30 January 2013

Jacintha Saldanha Should Not Be Treated As A Martyr

Jacintha Saldanha, a 46 year old Indian-origin nurse working in the UK, committed suicide on 7 December 2012. Saldanha fell for a prank call by a couple of Australian DJs who pretended to be the British Queen and called the hospital where Saldanha worked and where Kate Middleton had been admitted for morning sickness. Saldahna who answered the call, passed it on to the duty nurse, who too swallowed the accent hook, line and sinker, and passed on a lot of personal information pertaining to the princess. The DJs had a ball, until 3 days later, Saldanha committed suicide. You can read full details of this incident on Wikipedia and other websites. You can hear a recording of the prank call from this You Tube upload.

In the wake of Saldanha’s suicide, there were widespread demands, especially in India, for punishing the two Australian DJs. I don’t want to be an apologist for those two. What they did, with the benefit of hindsight, was reprehensible. It is also possible that they broke Australian privacy laws when they recorded a private conversation without the consent of one party. In India there was widespread sympathy and support for Saldanha who was seen as a victim and a martyr. I also got the feeling that many Indian news reports seem to suggest that Saldanha was driven to suicide by this incident, though according to this report, she had attempted suicide twice before.

The Catholic Church takes the stand that committing suicide is a grave sin and traditionally refuses to accord a standard funeral with religious rites. However, in Saldahna’s case, an exception seems to have been made.

I waited until now to write this post so that emotions would have calmed down and this is what I have to say.

Committing suicide is wrong, whatever be the circumstances or provocation. There was a time not so long ago when committing suicide was an offence under the Indian Penal Code. One who fumbled in a suicide attempt had to face criminal charges on top of everything else. These days, it is no longer a crime to attempt suicide, and rightly so. A person who attempts suicide and fails deserves support. However, that still does not make it the right thing to do. Was the prank played on Jacintha Saldanha so destructive that she had to commit suicide? I don’t think so. Let’s not forget the fact that Saldanha made a mistake by transferring the call. It was negligence, no doubt about it and if the hospital had taken disciplinary action against Saldanha, such action would have been justified. A receptionist isn’t meant to transfer calls just like that. True, Saldanha was not a trained receptionist, but these are basic things.

I don’t know if the hospital was planning to penalise Saldanha or if she was being bullied by her colleagues on account of her faux pas. We won’t know if Saldanha lacked family support at a time of crisis. We do know that Saldanha found day-to-day living unbearable and made a third attempt to kill herself. This time she succeeded.

India’s suicide rate is higher than the world average and Bangalore, which is not far from Saldahna’s native Mangalore, is considered to be the suicide capital of India. In many societies, it is morally acceptable to commit suicide in certain circumstances, such as when there is loss of honour etc. However, rather than make a martyr of Jacintha Saldahna, a message needs to be sent out that even in circumstances such as those Saldanha found herself in, committing suicide is not the right thing to do.

Sunday, 27 January 2013

Book Review: Our Moon has Blood Clots, by Rahul Pandita


There are many recorded instances of victims of discrimination, violence or even genocide dishing out similar treatment to others. Kurds, long oppressed by the Arabs and later by the Ottoman Turks, were instrumental in the Armenian genocide during the First World War. Jews, who fled the Nazis and settled in Palestine, haven’t been too kind to Palestinians. In Sri Lanka, the LTTE was rather nasty to the Muslim community in areas under its control, at times forcing Muslims to vacate places like Chavakacheri and Jaffna enmasse. Poles, who were at the receiving end of multiple aggressors ranging from Russians and Germans to Tartars, are rather anti-Semitic even now. To a certain extent, the violence unleashed by the Kashmiri Muslim community against Pandits living in the Valley falls in this category. Kashmiri Muslims may claim with some justification that they have received a raw deal from the Indian government and the earlier Dogra rulers. However, their treatment of the Pandits whom they drove away from the valley in increasing numbers since 1990 will always be remembered as yet another instance of a majority community oppressing a defenceless minority community.

Rahul Pandita, currently an Associate editor at the Open Magazine, and author of Hello Bastar, an account of India’s Maoist movement, tells the story of how his family was forced to flee to Jammu from the Kashmir valley when he was fourteen and live in squalid camps where his mother never tired of telling people that their house in the valley had 22 rooms. Pandita’s favourite cousin Ravi stayed on in the valley and was killed along with two others as they travelled by bus. There is no doubt that countless other Pandits have similar stories to tell.

In Our Moon has Blood Clots, Pandita doesn’t offer any answers, despite the innumerable questions that pop up during the discourse. Pandita makes a half-hearted attempt to be neutral and unbiased, there are references to how Dogras rulers were ‘rough’ with the Muslim community and how Hindus in Jammu tried to exploit the refugees from the Valley, but the book is almost entirely the story of the Pandit exodus and Pandita doesn’t even try to present the other side’s point of view. I don’t blame him. Pandita’s pain is still too raw and fresh to even think of making an attempt to provide the other side of the story, though Pandita makes it clear that he has maintained his humanism throughout. Once at a television studio for a debate on human rights, as Pandita argued in support of a zero tolerance approach in respect of human rights violations in Kashmir, he was reprimanded by a drunk army general who reminded him that the militants whose human rights he advocated had forced him out of his home. ‘General, I’ve lost my home, not my humanity,’ Pandita retorted.

Pandita makes it clear that the atrocities (murder and rape) against Pandits were carried out by fellow Kashmiris, with a different religious persuasion, and not just by foreign militants who came from across the LoC. Pandita tells us that divide between the Pandits and Muslims existed much before 1990. Cricket matches between India and Pakistan always brought the differences to the fore. The Muslims in Kashmir supported Pakistan and the Pandits naturally rooted for India. On April 18, 1986, when Javed Miandad hit Chetan Sharma’s last ball for a six in Sharjah, ‘ít was as if it was Diwali in Kashmir. I think every cracker available in Kashmir was burst in the next one hour. People streamed out of their houses and on to the streets chanting Allah ho Akbar. In the nippy April weather of the Valley, people drank gallons of Limca to celebrate, the way they had seen cricket stars celebrate with champagne.' Earlier, on October 13, 1983, when India had played Pakistan in Srinagar, the first ever international cricket match held in Jammu & Kashmir, the stadium had erupted in support for Pakistan. Vengsarkar was hit with a half-eaten apple. Pandita and his cousin Ravi had watched with disbelief. Was it always like that? Did Kashmiri Muslims always support the Pakistani cricket team since the time of the Partition? Pandita doesn’t provide a clear answer.

Pandita uses Ravi’s father as a narrator to describe the lie of the land at the time of the invasion by tribal levies immediately after the Partition. One gets the feeling that at that time the divide between Pandits and Muslims wasn’t so wide, though it did exist. Pandita doesn’t make it very clear when exactly the Hindu-Muslim divide grew to the extreme proportions one sees now.

In 1990, did Governor Jagmohan encourage Pandits to leave the Valley so that he could take stringent measures against the militants? Pandita rubbishes this theory. According to Pandita, Jagmohan was helpless. The administration had collapsed completely and sections of the state police were sympathetic to militants.

Even before I reached the end of the book I started wondering why the Indian government wasn’t taking more steps to make it possible for Pandits to return to the Valley. Create settlements for them, my brain screamed. When I reach the end of Pandita’s memoir, I find out that the Indian government has done just that and it isn’t working very well. A few thousand needy Pandits have moved back to the Valley and live in protected settlements which lack basic facilities. When they venture out in public, they, especially women, are targeted and harassed. The divide between Muslims and Pandits remains as wide as ever.

An honest account and a very good one at that, Our Moon has Blood Clots is a must read for anyone interested in the Kashmir dispute.

Friday, 25 January 2013

Hajj Tales

Two of my friends, a married couple, both practising Muslims, recently performed Hajj. A few months after their return from Mecca and Medina, I persuaded them to tell me about their experiences, which they graciously did.

Winnowed: Relief, Happiness, Exhilaration, Exhaustion, Joy. Which of these would have described your emotions best when you reached Mecca?

Friends: A bit of all of those. But mainly, we found it overwhelming. Overwhelming due to the crowds, the mix of nationalities, the different languages, the emotions one witnesses in others, the items to be ticked off the list to complete Hajj, but most important of all, to walk the roads the Prophet (SAW) walked on, to set eyes on the home he lived in (in Medina), to offer prayers at the mosques he built and prayed at (in Mecca and Medina) and to visit his final resting place (in Medina). We saw pilgrims from all over the world, speaking different languages but all with a common purpose. [The abbreviation ‘SAW’ stands for “salla Allahu alaihi wa-sallam”, which in Arabic means “May Allah's peace and blessings be upon the Prophet”]

Winnowed: Is there a limitation on the number of Hajjis each year or limitations on the number of times one can perform Hajj?

Friends: Technically I don’t think there is any restriction in Islam on the number of times Hajj can be performed (one can even perform Hajj on behalf of others who have either passed away before doing Hajj or are living but unable to perform the journey themselves). But due to the large number of Muslims, Saudi Arabia, which is the custodian of both holy sites, has fixed a quota for each country.

Winnowed: So you might want to go and you might not be able to?

Friends: Yes, you need to register in advance.

Winnowed: Was it a lifelong desire to perform Hajj or was it a sudden decision?

Friends: Definitely not a lifelong desire, we started thinking of it in terms of practicality especially after most of our family performed Hajj in the past few years and shared their experiences. It is a common belief that one goes when Allah Almighty calls for you. Kaaba is after all considered to be the home of Allah!

Kaaba


Ariel view of the Kaaba


Winnowed: Did you take your kids along?

Friends: No, we did not. Though many people visit with kids we did not think it practical to take kids who won’t understand any of it and we couldn’t have experienced Hajj the same way with kids! Our parents came over to look after them while we were away.

Winnowed: Aw! Lucky you! Now tell me about your actual journey? How did you get to Mecca? Did you travel with a plane-load of other pilgrims?

Friends: We travelled to Jeddah by Cathay Pacific. There are multiple points from where pilgrims come – for example, pilgrims from the US come via Dubai. It was a normal flight and we did have fellow Hajjis, our luggage had special Hajj stamps on them and we enjoyed a complimentary upgrade to business class! From Jeddah we took a Saudia flight to Medina. You also have the option to travel to Mecca directly by bus (there are no flight connections to Mecca – if I am not mistaken there is a restriction on flying over Mecca) or you can also take a bus to Medina.

Winnowed: Stupid question, but is it necessary to go to Medina at all? Can’t you perform Hajj by visiting Mecca alone?

Friends: Depends. Most people, despite their beliefs, will most likely go to Medina as that is the final resting place of the Prophet (SAW) and many of his family and he did live there for many years.

Winnowed: Can you go on Hajj at any time of the year?

Friends: Pilgrimage in the month of Zilhaj and during the specific days is called Hajj. At any other time of the year it is Umrah and carried less sawab (not compulsory and not as “rewarding”).

Winnowed: What are the Hajj days?

Friends: 8 to 13 of Zilhaj are the Hajj days. Hajjis tie their ahram on 8th and proceed to Mina immediately with minimum belongings. Ahram is the white clothing that Hajjis wear. Women can wear stitched clothing but men just wear two pieces of cloth – one wrapped around their upper body like a shawl and second like a lungi around their lower torso. Feet and face must remain open at all times and men will not cover their heads with a topi (not even at prayer time). Women may wear socks but most prefer not to. Once ahram is worn it can only be removed after Hajj is completed! Some of the restrictions while you are in ahram are no cutting nails, hair must not break, you must not see your own reflection, face must not be covered at any time (care must be taken when you wash and wipe your face before prayers!), no marital relations, no fighting, no lying, no killing (not even mosquitoes!), no using perfumed toothpaste or soap or attar, no coloured clothing (bags and slippers can be coloured but not the clothing), etc.

Mina is also called the tent city and is perhaps the only place in the world which is occupied only during the Hajj days. Rest of the year it just lies empty! The whole place is full of tents which can occupy about 50 people at a time, it has electricity, toilet blocks and most important, air conditioning! After wearing ahram, Hajjis are not allowed to go back to Mecca until they have completed their rituals.

Mina, Tent City


On the next day, pilgrims proceed to Arafat. I would say this is the most important day of Hajj. Arafat is the name of a place where the jabal ul rahmat (meaning: mercy) is located. It is believed that anyone who faces the sun at the time of sunset and prays at this site is forgiven and cleansed of all previous sins.

After spending the day at Arafat, pilgrims proceed to spend the night under the stars (yes, armed with nothing but our chatais and plastic bags to collect stones for stoning the devil) in Muzdalifah. We select stones, say our prayers and go to sleep and then proceed to Mina on the next day to stone the biggest devil (there are three devils – small, medium and large). We will do this for the next three days. Men shave all their hair at this point (first ahram restriction falls away) and women cut a small lock as a token. Next each pilgrim offers a sacrifice of a goat or lamb or camel, as one wishes and can afford (second ahram restriction falls away). The Saudi government has a program where they distribute the meat all over the world.

Once this is done, Hajjis may return to Mecca to give their tawaf (seven circumambulations of the Kaaba equal to one tawaf and can take anywhere from 40 minutes to an hour and a half!). Once the tawaf is given and once you have walked seven times between Safa and Marwah you may remove your ahram, have a bath and wear coloured clothes again. Your Hajj is completed, you are officially a Haji and your sins, up to this point in time, are all forgiven. We return to Mina to sleep and stone the devils until the morning of the 13th coming to Mecca only during the day to give tawafs. Only after this point are pilgrims allowed to return to Mecca and sleep in Mecca.

Masjid ul Haram which houses the Kaaba. The holiest site for all Muslims


Winnowed: Can you tell me a bit more about the stoning the devil ritual? What’s the significance?

Friends: When Prophet Ebrahim (pbuh) was ordered by Allah Almighty to build the Kaaba, the devil tried to distract him thrice at three different places. The stones are placed (I think) in the same three locations. [‘pbuh’ is the commonly used abbreviation for ‘peace be upon him’]


The building on the far right houses the Three Devils

Winnowed: What are the chances of getting hurt while throwing the stones?

Friends: I think this used to be the place where stampedes used to happen but the Saudi government has organised the area so pilgrims can stone the devils at ground level or any of the two upper levels. As such, the crowds are controlled and better managed. There is also very heavy security/volunteers at most of these places and I suppose anyone misbehaving will be swiftly led out!

Winnowed: So you went to Medina, Mecca, Mina and then back to Mecca is it?

Friends: Yes. More like Medina, Mecca, Mina, Arafat, Muzdalifah, Mina and Mecca!

Winnowed: What are the other significant sites one sees in Medina and Mecca?

Friends: The Masjid ul Nabawi, which is the first mosque the Prophet (SAW) built when he came to Medina. A splendid structure, it has been expanded from its original size to accommodate the swell of pilgrims. It houses the Prophet’s (SAW) and his daughter Fatema’s (AS) homes and also the Prophet’s final resting place. One can still see the mimbar (meaning: platform) where he climbed to lead the prayers. [The abbreviation ‘AS’ means "Alayhi Salam", which in Arabic means "May Allah bless him"]

Masjid ul Nabawi

Masjid ul Nabawi during the day


Outside is jannatul baqi where many of the Prophet’s (SAW) family are buried including his son, grandson, his daughters and his aunts. Only men are allowed to enter the compound.

One also sees the Masjid ul Quba, which includes pointers to the old kibla viz baitul muqaddas or Jerusalem (kibla meaning: direction in which all muslims turn for their prayers) and the current kibla (i.e the Kaaba). There are several other mosques that one can visit which the Prophet (SAW) built in his time and where pilgrims try to offer their prayers.

In Mecca, one can visit the final resting place of the Prophet’s first wife, Khadija (AS).

One can also visit the Jabal (meaning: mountain) ul Noor (meaning: light) where the Prophet (SAW) received his first revelation. Many pilgrims climb up to the cave to visit this site. There are also some museums.

Masjid ul Shajarah at Medina. The Prophet (SAW) always visited this mosque when entering or leaving Medina

Winnowed: What about food and accommodation. When a few million people descend on a place at the same time, I can only imagine how crowded it must have been.

Friends: It depends, food and accommodation is organised by your community or the group that you are travelling with. Most of it is very well taken care of. The Saudi government offers lunch boxes and water bottles to all pilgrims that enter Mecca! Water fountains are abundant and food in Mecca is generally cheap and delicious!

The small group of people in green are cleaners. Amazingly they manage to clean up amongst such crowds


Winnowed: I guess some other communities or nationalities might have had better arrangements. Or worse.

Friends: Some are better than others but I suppose everyone tries to improve each year and no matter how well you do there is always scope for better arrangements! I suppose given the sudden influx of pilgrims it is hard to manage expectations and everyone just tries to do their best. It is a humbling experience to see the hard living conditions of many pilgrims, to see the aged and crippled walk along side but never complaining. Many visit with young children even newborns, all the children were so well behaved, I never heard any crying despite the glaring heat and crushing crowds! If this is not a miracle, what is?

Winnowed: Are men and women segregated when you pray?

Friends: In Medina, yes. In Mecca, no. The crowds are too vast in Mecca for any effective segregation.

Winnowed: Tell me something really extraordinary or beautiful about Mecca

Friends: One of the most beautiful things about Mecca is the abundance of zam zam water fountains near the Kaaba. The legend of zam zam is that Prophet Ebrahim (pbuh) went to Mecca to build the Kaaba with his wife, Haajar, and his son, Ismail, as he was ordered by Allah Almighty. Prophet Ismail (AS), was still an infant and dying of thirst while his mother ran seven times between the hills of Safa and Marwah to look for water. When she came back, her son knocked his heels in the sandy desert and water sprang out which is known as zam zam. The well of zam zam was hidden for many years afterwards and revealed to the Prophet’s (SAW) grandfather, Abdul Muttalib, in a dream. Since then, for more than 1400 years, this well of zam zam has not dried up. It is believed to have healing powers and all pilgrims drink this water to their fill after giving tawaf and even sprinkle some on their faces. Almost all pilgrims will bring back zam zam to give to family and friends. We brought back a 10 litre can!

Hill of Safa


Even today (though moved from its original position), there is a small structure that marks the place (called Makame Ebrahim) where Prophet Ebrahim (pbuh) stood and built the Kaaba. It is believed that a small semi circular area (which is cordoned off) is the final resting place of his son, Prophet Ismail (pbuh) (called Hijre Ismail). The well of zam zam is also located within the precincts of Kaaba but is no longer open to the public.

Winnowed: What about security arrangements in Mecca and Medina?

Friends: I saw a couple of road accidents. Security is very high (and conspicuous) in all public places.

Winnowed: Are you saying there wasn’t a single thing that you didn’t like about the entire pilgrimage? Nothing went wrong? (shaking my head in disbelief)

Friends: (with smiles) No, nothing went wrong. If at all we had to grumble, we would say that the Saudis could put in a bit more effort into signposting especially in multiple languages in Mina, since you have to walk everywhere and it is just very easy to get lost (which does not sound too bad but is actually very scary).

Tuesday, 1 January 2013

A Crying Need For Police Reform – A Few Suggestions

The recent incident in Delhi of a gruesome rape leading to murder of a young 23 year old girl has once again highlighted the urgent need to revamp and reform India’s police forces. The Indian Police was set up by the British on the lines of the Royal Irish Constabulary, a semi-military force meant to suppress the local population at the behest of the colonial masters. It’s time the police forces are re-structured.

The problem

India’s police constables and havildars, the public face of the police force, are corrupt. The Sub-Inspectors and Circle Inspectors to whom they report are also corrupt. There are a number of IPS officers, India’s smartest and brightest, who are intelligent and civil and honest, but when was the last time a citizen walked into a police station and was met by an IPS officer? When I say the low-ranking policemen are corrupt, I don’t just mean they are lazy or unmotivated or indifferent. They are all that, but I mean corrupt as in bribe-taking corrupt. Most policemen take bribes and the pickings are usually far in excess of their salaries. Bribes are taken for not enforcing the law or for letting someone off the hook or not torturing a suspect or to do their jobs. Since most policemen are busy augmenting their incomes, they do not have the time or will to serve the public. Also, any attempt to change the status quo is met with a lot of resistance since change has a negative impact on the policeman’s wallet.

On top of such bribe taking, most low ranking policemen espouse values that do not belong to the 21st century. They do not think it is a good idea for teenagers to date or party or for adults to display their affections in public. They think it’s wrong for women to wear western outfits, but see nothing wrong in a Bollywood dance with its interesting gyrations.

Possible Solutions

Here are a few suggestions for reforming India’s police forces.

1. Currently anyone with a higher secondary school certificate can apply to be a police constable. Let’s make it mandatory for an individual to have a college degree before joining the police.

2. Encourage immigrants to join the police. Even in cities like Mumbai and Delhi which have large numbers of immigrants from other parts of India, very few immigrants (or their children) enter the police in the lower ranks. A concerted effort has to be made to induct Indians from other parts of India to join various state forces. A more cosmopolitan force will be more humane.

3. Create a civilian component in the police force. A number of functions currently being carried out by policemen can be done by civilians. One of the most important police functions is the recording of FIRs. Everyone knows how difficult and painful it is to go to a police station and record an FIR. Currently, FIRs are taken down by constables in an indecipherable handwriting, usually in the local language and recorded in a well-thumbed register. This has to change. We need to set up FIR recording centres, which are not controlled or run by policemen, where civilians can take down reports of offences and pass them to the relevant police stations. It should also be possible to report an offence by phone. Every state should have an central FIR station, modelled on the lines of a call centre, where hundreds of civilian employees take down details of complaints over the phone and process them. At least 50% of those civilians should be women.

4. Every FIR must go into a central database and should be in English as well as the regional language. Civilian employees should monitor the progress of the investigation from a central control room. If no progress is made within a reasonable time, the responsible police station should receive a rocket.

5. Time-sheets for policemen. Every policeman at the end of his shift should enter a timesheet setting out his activities for the day. How did he spend his working hours? Was he helping the public or swatting flies or shaking down traffic offenders for a few hundreds?

6. Policing is a process. Break it up. From noting down an FIR to investigating an offence to charging an accused of an offence to producing him or her in court, everything is a process, which can be broken up and delegated. A number of these functions can be performed by the civilian component. For example, the time sheet filled in by constables should be handed over to a civilian employee for data entry every day. Armed/trained police should mainly be involved in patrolling, investigation and controlling mobs.

7. Setting priorities for the police. It’s easier to go for soft targets, like rounding up teenagers holding hands, than to fight organised crime. Priorities for the police must not be decided by the police. Rather, it must be decided by the Home Ministry and publicised. If police conduct a number of raids on late night parties but do not arrest the dadas who collect hafta from street hawkers, someone must have a fair amount of explaining to do.

8. Should the police force in each town or district report to locally elected representatives such as corporators or municipal councillors? This may work, but we need to consider that many local politicians are quite corrupt and they could get into cahoots with the policemen who report to them. Should we create a post of Police Sheriff and hold elections for this post? Communities will get the sort of policing they want. This could however result in a perpetuation of local values. Khap panchayats might rule! A better alternative would be to merely provide for greater transparency in the workings of the police. We could publicise details of crimes reported to the police, action taken by the police and the end result on a public database.